Here's an engaging story inspired by a true case to answer a key question for successful business owners:

Can you be bound to a written agreement by your course of conduct even though you never signed the written agreement?

Echoes of Agreement: How Actions Speak Louder Than Signatures

In the charming town of Riverton Falls, Oregon, nestled between lush forests and a meandering river, the legal saga involving Ethan Carter and the prestigious law firm of Hamilton, Reid, Bancroft & Shaw (HRBS) unfolded, capturing the attention of the local professional community and challenging the core values of partnership and fidelity that had long united them.

Ethan, affectionately known by his peers as "Carter," had made his mark as an accomplished equity partner at HRBS, a firm renowned for its sharp expertise in business law. Despite its accolades, HRBS operated without a formal written partnership agreement, a seemingly minor oversight that would later become the focal point of a bitter dispute.

The narrative took a pivotal turn in late 2018 when HRBS, recognizing the necessity for more structured governance, initiated the drafting of a comprehensive partnership agreement. As part of this initiative, Carter and his fellow partners were asked to review and comment on the draft. Carter, however, raised objections to a provision that would curtail the compensation for partners who left the firm to continue their legal practice elsewhere.

Feeling hemmed in by this stipulation and yearning for a venture where he could wield greater autonomy, Carter began to contemplate an independent path. With a mix of ambition and resolve, he formed a new alliance with two of HRBS's partners. This nascent partnership, born out of a shared vision for the future, marked the beginning of a new chapter for Carter.

However, this venture was short-lived, crumbling under the weight of unforeseen challenges. By December 2018, Carter had decided to accept an offer from another firm and tendered his resignation from HRBS on the first day of the new year, 2019. In a turn of events that Carter had not anticipated, HRBS declined to buy out his equity share, a courtesy traditionally extended to retiring partners.

Feeling aggrieved, Carter initiated legal proceedings against HRBS, sparking a complex legal battle that explored deep issues of partnership law and fiduciary responsibilities. In response, HRBS filed a counterclaim, intensifying the legal confrontation.

During the proceedings, Carter contended that he was not bound by the partnership agreement implemented after his departure since he had not consented to it as a partner. Nonetheless, the court determined that an unwritten agreement had been effectively formed through the consistent words and actions of the partners, including Carter. This implied agreement dictated the terms for compensating partners upon their exit, ruling that HRBS was not required to purchase Carter's equity share.

Conclusion

As the legal dust settled and the community of Riverton Falls reflected on the saga of Ethan Carter and HRBS, a valuable lesson emerged, resonating far beyond the courtroom:

Remember: You can be bound to a contract not just by your signature, but also by your words and actions.

Are you wondering about any of the issues mentioned above? Please email us at info@wilkinsonlawllc.com or call (732) 410-7595 for assistance.

At Wilkinson Law, we give business owners the documents and advice they desperately need to fund, grow, protect and sell their businesses. We are trustworthy business advisors keeping your business on TRACK: Trustworthy. Reliable. Available. Caring. Knowledgeable.®