Here's an engaging story inspired by a true case to answer a key question for successful business owners:

When someone gives you bad advice, can you successfully sue them even without a contract?

The Hidden Risks of Free Advice

Mike Thompson, owner of Ace Payment Solutions, prided himself on providing top-notch service to small businesses in his hometown of Springfield. With years of experience installing credit card terminals, he had built a reputation for reliability and expertise. So when Bella Martinez, owner of Bella's Boutique, approached him to upgrade her payment system, Mike was more than happy to help.

Bella's Boutique was thriving, and she wanted to speed up customer checkout by removing the signature line requirement on her new point-of-sale (POS) terminal. Mike had recently purchased a state-of-the-art POS terminal from Retail Hardware Supply Co., a third-party vendor. Confident in his abilities but unfamiliar with this specific request, Mike decided to reach out to TechPOS Inc., the manufacturer of the terminal, for guidance.

He called TechPOS's customer support line and was connected with a representative named Alex. "No problem," Alex assured him. "I can walk you through the steps to disable the signature line." Mike carefully followed Alex's instructions, making sure each step was executed precisely. After completing the process, the terminal functioned smoothly, and Bella was delighted with the faster checkout experience.

However, a few weeks later, Bella noticed a disturbing trend. Transactions that appeared as "approved" on the terminal were not showing up in her bank account. Alarmed, she contacted Mike to investigate the issue. Mike dove into the problem, retracing his steps and verifying the terminal settings. Realizing that the issue stemmed from the changes he made under TechPOS's guidance, Mike felt responsible for the financial losses Bella had incurred.

Bella calculated that she had lost over $3,000 in unprocessed sales. Committed to maintaining his business's reputation and valuing his relationship with Bella, Mike decided to reimburse her for the full amount. While this gesture preserved his client relationship, it left a significant dent in his own finances.

Feeling that TechPOS's faulty advice led to this predicament, Mike sought compensation from them. He reached out to TechPOS, explaining the situation and requesting reimbursement for the losses he covered. The company was unresponsive, prompting Mike to take legal action. He filed a lawsuit against TechPOS Inc., alleging that their inadequate customer support and incorrect instructions led to his financial damages.

In the trial court, Mike presented his case, detailing his interactions with TechPOS's customer support and the subsequent fallout. The court sympathized with his plight, concluding that a contractual relationship existed based on the exchange of services—specifically, the advice provided by TechPOS and Mike's reliance on that advice. The court ruled in his favor, awarding him $3,042 to cover his losses.

TechPOS Inc., however, was not satisfied with this outcome and decided to appeal the decision. Their legal team argued that no enforceable contract existed between Mike and TechPOS. They contended that any use of their customer support services was governed by their End User License Agreement (EULA), which Mike had neither seen nor agreed to. Furthermore, they claimed that providing customer support did not constitute entering into a contract.

The appellate court reviewed the case with a critical eye. They noted that while Mike did receive instructions from TechPOS, there was no concrete evidence of a formal agreement outlining obligations and remedies between the parties. The court stated that assumptions of a contract based solely on customer support interactions were insufficient grounds for legal liability. Without a clear contract specifying the terms and conditions, they could not hold TechPOS accountable for the damages Mike incurred.

In the end, the appellate court overturned the trial court's decision. Mike was left to absorb the financial loss, a harsh reminder of the complexities of business dealings without explicit agreements.

Remember: Getting bad advice without a contract is just tough luck.

Are you wondering about any of the issues mentioned above? Please email us at info@wilkinsonlawllc.com or call (732) 410-7595 for assistance.

At Wilkinson Law, we give business owners the clarity they need to fund, grow, protect, and sell their businesses. We are trustworthy business advisors keeping your business on TRACK: Trustworthy. Reliable. Available. Caring. Knowledgeable.®